Apologies in advance. This is going to be a bit of a rambling post. I have no idea where this will go, or even exactly what questions I am going to ask let alone attempt any answers. It will have even less structure than normal. So look away now if you want any sense.
I’ve played a bit with Twilight of the Soldier Kings since being introduced to the Twilight series of Wargames rules. And very impressed I have been. It’s revived my Frederician mojo somewhat. Earlier this year (thinks: it was this year wasn’t it?) I played a few solo games of Loose Files and American Scramble, and those rules proved every bit as fun as I hoped they’d be. And they seemed to capture something of the nature of that conflict too (AWI). I also snuck in a game set in the Continuation War with my own ‘back of a fag packet’ rules. That too was fun. Ditto an ECW game with my own rules. What next?
Napoleonics is the only one of my five periods that I haven’t touched so far this year. But for no apparent reason, that doesn’t appeal.
I did begin the year with the intention of running an ECW campaign off the back of the This War Without an Enemy board game that I bought for my other half to give me for Christmas. For reasons explained previously this wasn’t terribly practicable. I’ve been tempted to run a campaign using other, or no, rules but I can’t quite get the motivation yet. Alternative campaign models are those produced by Peter of Gridded Wargames, Almost but not Quite, or latterly by The Jolly Broom Man on his latest blog. Both of those would fit the bill of being relatively admin light. Something, I know not what, is holding me back. At this juncture I could really delve into an introspective self-examination (and I think that would bear fruit, trust me) but right now I can’t be arsed.
It is after all a hobby. It shouldn’t be work. And introspection right now feels like hard work. I want a quick fix. But what?
The ECW is calling me. I’ve been reading David Cooke’s ‘Yorkshire Sieges of the Civil Wars’. I currently have limited ‘apparatus’ to do a siege game. I know I should use this to spur me on to make some. But, well. I want something now. Cooke’s ‘Civil War in Yorkshire’ book has some interesting small scale scenarios I could look at. The battle of Seacroft Moor 1643 appeals. But then so does Domstadl from the SYW in 1758. Neither are stand up battles, so they give Both took place over a large area with relatively small forces. That poses a challenge in both cases too. I’d have to find a way of dealing with the operational aspects in order to make on table actions meaningful.
Another option swirling around my head is an action based on a relief of a besieged place. If it’s not to just be another stand-up fight (albeit with a backstory) it needs a bit of thought around the scenario and how the game is set-up.
‘No biggie’ you might think. There are always ways to do this. But it needs a bit of thought. And that is in short supply at the moment. Or is it the motivation that is lacking? I sort of know what I want but lack the mental or psychological resources at the moment to achieve it.
Hmmm.
What is it that you really want to do? Prioritize and tackle each, one at a time.
ReplyDeleteNormally I wouldn’t hesitate to do that Jon. Narrowing down the focus isn’t so much the issue. Not now I’ve attempted to put something down in writing. It’s working up a solution that I’m struggling with.
DeleteBased upon my experience i found the following helps and works for me:
ReplyDelete- Take a step back and not think about this for a few days and then come back to it with 'fresh eyes'. Alongside this go for a good solo walk or bike ride. Both of these tend to give me some clarity of vision as to what do I really want to achieve.
- Narrative campaigns I've found to be the easiest way to generate a series of linked games with minimal effort, yet give meaning to each games outcomes. You can start small with some skirmish action, which lead up to increasingly bigger engagements until you end up with your climatic battle.
- A bit of an obvious statement but find a set of rules you will be happy with, which is easier said than done! I'm a fan of keeping things simple here and so go down the Black Powder stable of rules as the mechanisms are broadly the same, so I can chop and change periods with minimal effort.
As I said they work for me, but may not work for you, but I hope they may spark some ideas to help resolve your impasse.
Thanks for your ideas Steve. Taking a step back is maybe the key.
DeleteI enjoyed my mini narrative campaigns. I’d like something a little more rule driven to take more of the control away from me this time. To allow for more possibilities. Having said that, the scenarios I mentioned are pretty much stand alone.
The basic tactical rules I’m happy with, so no trouble there.
Bob Cordery Pike and Shot book has seige rules in it as well as excellent rules for the period. I have Wargamed ecw on and off since my teens. It is a terrific period.
ReplyDeleteI’ve been meaning to take a look at that. I need some fortress models first. I’m good for earthworks for the besiegers.
DeleteA campaign based around a siege is milling around my head.
Hey mate. Have you got the time money and resources to start again on something entirely new or are you intending to do something new with what you’ve already got? I’ve been collecting Franco Prussian war stuff for the last month or so since I’ve been in the same situation you now find yourself in. It’ll come to you, trust me.
ReplyDeleteWhy are you selling? 😆
DeleteI’m not feeling bored with the periods I’ve got, though I’ve long had a hankering for something ‘colonial’. And ancients (Punic Wars).
I’d sell my 6mm ECW with scenery, but nowt else!
DeleteMy advice would be....don't stress about it! As you said, it's a hobby, not a job, it should not be an effort! If nothing is happening for you at the moment, just do something else...read or watch Netflix or go walking or whatever. In my experience, your enthusiasm/mojo for wargaming will return without conscious effort from you!
ReplyDeleteSound advice. I sometimes find it difficult to switch off when I’ve got something in my mind. Same with work.
DeleteI am the last one to offer advice on regaining motivation.. but I would mention that the pubs are open again.. get down your favourite one, sit in the sun with a pint or two... and something will come along even if it's only a packet of cheese and onion.. ;o)
ReplyDeleteCheese and onion. Now you’re talking. With a nice IPA.
DeleteAn interesting read perhaps not for the specific details but it reflects the thought processes which I suspect are working in most wargamers heads most of the time. If you walked into my hobby space, you would see the final throws of an AWI battle, I am painting ACW unit but they are sat next to some Hessians and some SYW 10 mm ...but I am thinking about Napoleonics, and tanks and AWI cavalry oh and those RCW reinforcements. For me this distraction is healthy and good and my philosophy is go with the flow it is my hobby and I will do what I fancy 👍
ReplyDeleteMaybe you are spreading your energy a bit too thinly? For many years your focus was almost entirely on the wars of Old Fritz? Now you've found a new set of large battle rules for that period that inspires you why not focus on a mid-C18th campaign?
ReplyDeleteI don’t think I am. I just fancy doing something with the ECW. My problem doesn’t seem to be lack of focus as much lack of inspiration/ideas to achieve what I want to do without too much time or effort.
DeleteTime/space is the other limiting factor.